Hey Bookworm friends! When some friends and I picked Bromantasy to read together I was excited because it sounded silly and fun. Unfortunately it didn’t work for me on any possible level. Heads up, 1 star spoiler-filled rant upcoming—avert your eyes if that’s not something you’re interested in. I probably should have DNF’d it but I was holding on to hope that some sort of reveal would make it all come together in the end. It didn’t, sadly. Anyway, onto the nitty-gritty.
❗Please note that this review will contain spoilers. Take this as your warning and read at your own risk!
Disclaimer: If I hate a book other readers love it’s not a personal judgement of them. We all look for different things in books when we read and I have no patience for shaming people for their reading preferences.
Book Details
Bromantasy
by Máire Roche
Genre: Romantasy
Standalone
Publisher: G.P. Putnam’s Sons
Format Read: Audiobook
Narrator: Mark Sanderlin
Pub Date: May 26, 2026
Cover Artist: Tal Goretsky
Themes & Tropes
Friends to Lovers │Questing│ Two Heroes. One Brain Cell │ Only One Bed │MM Romance
Content Warnings:
Child Abuse, Abandonment, Death of Parent, Alcoholism, Sexual Content, Injury, Fire
⟡
Blurb
Click to Open
Fellas, is it gay to kiss your bff while on a quest through the forest you’re unqualified for?
Juniper O’Reilly is good at only two things: demolishing a pint of mead and finding the perfect skincare routine. Everything else—taking care of the farm, bartering for goods, any sort of manual labor—falls to Juniper’s best friend, the absurdly capable, endlessly patient Mo Elmthorn.
But when Juniper accidentally volunteers them both for a quest to kill a fearsome monster, he knows he’s finally gotten in over his head. Juniper hates camping, he hates the dark, and there’s no way all these foraged mushrooms are going to sit well in his stomach. One thing he doesn’t hate? How good Mo’s thighs look in his questing pants—he doesn’t have time to think about that, though, with a monster to hunt and their futures on the line.
But monsters come in all shapes and sizes. When Juniper and Mo realize that the terrifying beast they’ve sworn to kill is just a scared little girl torn from their family, they’re off to find not only the true villain of the story, but maybe even a happy ending.
Review
The story is about best friends, Juniper and Mo, who moved in together when they were about 19 winters old. They love to eat cheese, pet their cat, and get into tavern brawls for fun. One day, Juniper gets into an ill-advised brawl with someone they shouldn’t and both friends end up conscripted into a dragon hunt that neither of them is equipped for.
The best way for me to explain what didn’t work for me is to break down the book title into its parts. Bro. Romance. Fantasy.
Where is the Bro?
We’re told these two are like two peas in a pod but when the story starts they’ve been living together for ten years and are already on quite rocky terrain. We don’t actually get to see them spending much time together when neither of them is mad at the other. For a couple of ‘best friends’ they don’t even listen to what the other person has to say. Juniper is extremely whiny and naive while Mo is willfully obtuse yet convinced that only he knows how to make correct decisions in regards to the quest they’re on. By the midway point of the book, they’ve lost so much trust in each other that Mo readily believes lies about Juniper from their enemy and it makes no sense. I genuinely don’t think that their friendship had a steady foundation to begin with.
Where is the Romance?
The narration makes constant references to how these two are just roommates and best friends and nothing more 😉. There is tension because ten years ago they woke up in the same bed and then Mo promptly left so the reader is left wondering what the heck happened. The problem is that so are they because they’ve never talked about it! It’s painfully obvious that both characters are in love with each other but they’re unwilling to admit it to themselves or to each other. This gets old real fast. Any time either of them has a feeling, they literally wrestle about it instead of talking. And they’re supposed to be adults. In a world with dragons, this is the most unbelievable part of it all.
“Do we always have to brawl?”
“What, did you think we were going out for tea and biscuits and to cross our ankles and politely gossip about the queen’s new wigs?”
By the midway point, I was fed up with these two but I was trying to reserve judgement to see what happened ten years ago that wrecked their friendship to this level. Frustratingly, it was the most anticlimactic and boring answer of all. Turns out they were each making assumptions about what the other person wanted. Meaning that the entire tension of this book hinged on these alleged best friends not having an honest conversation for ten years. Which made it all the more jarring when finally they admitted their feelings for each-other and jumped directly into dirty-talk. Like, you couldn’t say a word for a decade and now you’ve skipped SO many steps? The tone was just all over the place!
Where is the Fantasy?
Okay, so the plot let me down, but what about the setting? We’re supposed to be in a fantasy world with dragons right? We do meet one and I absolutely loved her! Too bad we barely got to spend any time with her because she immediately gets kidnapped and then the Bros spend the rest of the time arguing about how to help save her. And that’s the other thing, the fantasy adventure is not very adventurous either, it’s just running back and forth in the forest with no plan. At least I can say that the ‘One Brain Cell’ part of the marketing was the only accurate part.
The cover looks like such a cozy fantasy world and I did enjoy the cozy feel of the start of the book when they’re in their cottage. Once they leave on the quest the world-building suffers, though. I could not tell you anything about the world these characters live in aside from I know the king wants to hunt dragons. I didn’t feel like I lived there with the characters because the setting was painted in a very surface way.
“While Juniper’s stories were cozy little adventures, sparks that had barely escaped the hearth fire, Mo’s stories were full of faraway places that left home burning in their wake.”
Are you tired of hearing my litany of complaints yet? I’m sorry. And I have one more (I promise this is the last one) 🙈. The writing style itself didn’t work for me either. It was full of modern sayings and internet-speak such as “in this economy”, “circling back”, “un-alive”, and “in their [blank] era” to give a few examples. This type of slang in stories is my number one pet peeve; it yanks me out of the story every time! I know it was meant to be humorous but it just didn’t land with me.
Alas, I’ll need to look elsewhere for better friends-to-lovers books. And who knows maybe other people will have better luck with this book, it certainly seems very love-it or hate-it based on other reviews I’ve seen. 🤷🏼♀️

Let’s chat in the comments!
What’s your number one pet peeve in stories? Or have you read this one and do you agree or disagree with my take?

